A BioShock Review

Nxs · 08-20-2007, 07:20 PM

This review is soooo bad and biased, I don't even know where to start! I am sure you guys will have something to say about it

dopey1467 · 08-20-2007, 07:34 PM

That page doesn't like to be viewed, refresh it a little if you get the 'Service Temporarily Unavailable' crap.

Im not going to fully comment on the review until I give the Demo a try on the PC later on :P. Never like the Xbox360 so im just going to blame it on the fact that the game was being played off the console :P.

The trailers and in-game videos seems pretty impressive, so when the download finishes and I have a little go of the demo then I shall comment :P.

modock22 · 08-20-2007, 07:41 PM

ok we all know i'm not a fan of the ps3. I have said my share of bad thiings about it. and i'm starting to think the sdf is a knee jerk reaction to the bad word of mouth. i mean come on. bioshock has some of the bast graphics i have seen to date! that review is useless!

Gazz · 08-20-2007, 07:46 PM

Lol, I prefer the PS3 since it doesn't fail too much and it's way more future proof but this is so biased... Hell, does this guy even know it's going to be released on PS3 before the holiday season and with all the maps that didn't fit on the 360 disc (downloadable content on live soon btw)

Then again, the guy seems to have actually played the game and we all assume he's wrong. Perhaps we are the biased fanboys basing our view of the game on of just a few trailers here? It atleast gives you something to wonder about before slamming the guy who wrote this review.

Balmoung · 08-20-2007, 07:55 PM

LMFAO gotta love the part whith the dumbass saying im only gonna buy the game to make sure its NOT as god as people say...i might be wrong but isnt it smarter to just ignore the game if u think its bad instead of wasting money on it to say " yup i knew it its bad" and throw it in the garbage ..some people really need to think about what they typed and have it make sense..anyways i havent played the demo hell i havent even seen pics until today so i cant rate the game but i can at least say that the PS3 fanboys of that site are right hilarious

Nxs · 08-20-2007, 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Gazz@Aug 20 2007, 01:46 PM
Lol, I prefer the PS3 since it doesn't fail too much and it's way more future proof but this is so biased... Hell, does this guy even know it's going to be released on PS3 before the holiday season and with all the maps that didn't fit on the 360 disc (downloadable content on live soon btw)

Then again, the guy seems to have actually played the game and we all assume he's wrong. Perhaps we are the biased fanboys basing our view of the game on of just a few trailers here? It atleast gives you something to wonder about before slamming the guy who wrote this review.

Nooooo! We are not the ones that are biased! First off it is a bad review not only because of the blatant bias but, because it actually sucks! No self respecting reviewer would ever write some little short review that does not even cover the game play, let alone say it sux just because it is on a system he/she apparently has no love for! Seriously, this can not even be counted as a review. Even the most noobie reviewer would get fired for that kinda crap!

Now, I understand that some people are not going to like the game but, it sure as hell deserves better than a 5 out of 10! I also understand it is hard not to be biased when you are a reviewer but, if you can't do so, then you don't need to be reviewing anything.

64705 · 08-20-2007, 08:31 PM

I'm looking forward to the PC demo, but 1.8gb is huge! Nothing my 20mb connection can't deal with tho.

Gazz · 08-20-2007, 08:38 PM

Hell, I said the review was biased from my first line. I am just pointing out that it's tricky for us to judge a review or game based on trailers or demo's. Bioshock is probably going to rule but no one can be sure of that until they have played the final product and that might make every person who trashes this review even more biased and narrow minded then the absolute fanboy who actually wrote this.

Still, the guy has a point to wait for this gem to come out for PS3 because of the often discussed lack of space on the 360 disc if you wanna get this game on a console. Only idiots after all would want to play this game compressed and on a console that's infamous for it's high failure rate. It would suck if you were half way trough the game and you'd see some red light's. Ah well, I am getting this on PC so I'll be fine anyway.

I'd also like to state that sites like "Sony's defense site" and other sites like that suck balls. They are pathetic and only degrade Sony's cause.

Nxs · 08-20-2007, 09:11 PM

I don't see the problem with lack of space! PC users have had multiple discs for years! BG was 5 discs and UT2k4 was 3 I think and they both still sold amazingly well! I would have no problem switching discs to play a game I liked! Also, demos are supposed to give you an idea of how the game is so, it is fair to judge the demo almost like you would the game. Sure, there are a lot of ifs in there as not all demos show all the stuff that is in a game. Still, it is not that hard of a leap to make from demo to game.

I am pretty sure that the 360s failing has nothing to do with the game but more with the hardware so, I won't even go there! I am just calling the review as what I see it as, complete and utter crap!

Gazz · 08-20-2007, 09:16 PM

A short demo for instance doesn't give a gamer the impression that the full game might get repetitive and there are millions of others reasons why demos don't represent the final product. The console has everything to do with it, it's the machine that plays the game after all and it should be as good or better then the game you play on it. The 360 completely fails on numerous issues there.

Kinda like buying a great house on a crappy foundation

Ediut: installing a game once on pc and doing that continuously on a 360 can't be compared.